- Home
- Articles
- Which Elements Suit Earth on the City Wall? Compatible and Clashing Elements and Lucky Colors
Chinese Astrology
Which Elements Suit Earth on the City Wall? Compatible and Clashing Elements and Lucky Colors

In the Na Yin five-element system, Earth on the City Wall is likened to the layer of earth that forms sturdy rampart walls, able to protect and provide lasting stability. This image is tied to endurance, principle and a sense of responsibility. However, not every element has a generating relationship with Earth on the City Wall.
So which elements is Earth on the City Wall compatible with, which clash with it, and which colors should people of this Na Yin choose? To determine this, consider the five-element generating and controlling rules, while distinguishing the relationships between elements from the particular readings for each Na Yin.
What is Earth on the City Wall?
Earth on the City Wall is one of the six Na Yin of the Earth element, meaning the earth on top of a city wall or the earth of a rampart. In traditional feng shui, it is the image of earth built up and reinforced to protect an area, symbolizing solidity, endurance and stability.
The name consists of three classical elements. “Thanh” refers to ramparts and defensive works; “Dau” means on top; and “Tho” is earth. Together, the name expresses the layer of earth on top of the wall that forms a protective structure.
Unlike roadside or sandy earth, Earth on the City Wall is imagined as earth that has been heaped, compacted and reinforced. This is why the Na Yin is often associated with steadfastness, resilience and a spirit of preserving lasting values.
However, describing Earth on the City Wall as the sturdiest of the six Earth Na Yin is only symbolic. Na Yin are images in a calendar and feng shui system, not a geological classification of soils.
Which birth years are Earth on the City Wall?
According to the sixty-year Jiazi table, Earth on the City Wall corresponds to the Wu Yin and Ji Mao years. The stem-branch cycle repeats every 60 years, so birth years of this Na Yin recur accordingly.
| Birth year | Stem-branch | Zodiac animal | Na Yin element |
| 1938 | Wu Yin | Tiger | Earth on the City Wall |
| 1939 | Ji Mao | Cat | Earth on the City Wall |
| 1998 | Wu Yin | Tiger | Earth on the City Wall |
| 1999 | Ji Mao | Cat | Earth on the City Wall |
| 2058 | Wu Yin | Tiger | Earth on the City Wall |
| 2059 | Ji Mao | Cat | Earth on the City Wall |
People born in 1998 and 1999 are the two age groups most often mentioned when exploring Earth on the City Wall today.
Note that the Na Yin year in the table is determined by the lunar year. People born in January or early February should check whether their birthday falls after the Lunar New Year.
In addition, some Ba Zi schools set the turn of the year at Start of Spring. So using Na Yin by lunar age and setting up a Four Pillars chart should be clearly distinguished.
Which elements is Earth on the City Wall compatible with?
Under the five-element rules, Earth on the City Wall is compatible with Fire and Earth in terms of generating support and harmony. Metal also has a generating relationship with Earth on the City Wall in the direction of Earth generating Metal, but this is an outflowing relationship, unlike receiving support from Fire.
This principle comes from the generating cycle: Fire generates Earth, Earth generates Metal. In addition, Earth people share the same element as Earth on the City Wall.
Table of relationships between Earth on the City Wall and the five elements
| Element | Relationship with Earth on the City Wall | Five-element meaning |
| Fire | Generating, Fire generates Earth | Fire supports and nourishes Earth |
| Earth | Harmonizing | Same element, symbolizing stability |
| Metal | Earth generates Metal | Earth on the City Wall plays the outflowing role |
| Wood | Wood controls Earth | Controlling relationship, to be weighed |
| Water | Earth controls Water | Earth on the City Wall controls Water |
The table reflects the basic five-element principle. When looking in detail at each pair of Na Yin, some traditional texts also give other readings based on the particular image of each kind of earth, fire, water or metal.
Earth on the City Wall and Fire – a generating relationship
In the five elements, Fire generating Earth is one of the five basic generating relationships. Fire represents flame, and Earth represents soil. In the traditional explanation, matter that has burned can turn to ash and return to the earth.
For Earth on the City Wall, the image of rampart earth is also linked with firing materials to create a solid structure. So Fire is usually seen as a source of support for this Na Yin.
Earth on the City Wall people paired with Fire people are usually read as having supportive, driving and developing factors.
However, not every Fire Na Yin has the same effect in traditional readings.
Some Fire Na Yin usually considered with Earth on the City Wall
| Fire Na Yin | Typical birth years | Symbolic meaning |
| Fire in the Furnace | 1986, 1987 | Fire in a furnace, tied to smelting and firing |
| Fire on the Mountain Top | 1994, 1995 | Fire on the mountain |
| Thunderbolt Fire | 1948, 1949, 2008, 2009 | Lightning fire, strong and sudden in nature |
| Fire at the Foot of the Mountain | 1956, 1957, 2016, 2017 | Fire at the foot of the mountain |
| Lamp Fire | 1964, 1965, 2024, 2025 | Lamp fire |
| Heavenly Fire | 1978, 1979 | Fire in the sky |
In the general five-element relationship, all these Na Yin belong to Fire and generate Earth.
However, when reading Earth on the City Wall specifically, some texts hold that Thunderbolt Fire may harm the image of a rampart because of the violence of lightning. Conversely, some kinds of Fire associated with firing and smelting are interpreted as more favorable.
This shows the need to distinguish Fire generating Earth in the basic five elements from detailed compatibility readings between two Na Yin. Don’t assume that every Fire Na Yin is equally good for Earth on the City Wall.
Earth on the City Wall and Earth – a harmonizing relationship
People of the Earth element are usually seen as sharing similar five-element qualities. In feng shui belief, Earth symbolizes stability, endurance and the ability to build foundations.
So Earth on the City Wall combined with an Earth person is classed as a harmonizing relationship.
The image of rampart earth meeting more earth can suggest strengthening the foundation, increasing solidity and forming a more stable structure.
However, Earth also tends toward fixity. Judged only by imagery, the combination of two Earth factors could be read as overly cautious or inflexible in some situations.
Earth Na Yin usually considered with Earth on the City Wall
| Na Yin | Typical birth years | Image |
| Earth by the Roadside | 1990, 1991 | Earth by the roadside |
| Earth on the Roof | 1946, 1947, 2006, 2007 | Earth on the roof |
| Earth on the Wall | 1960, 1961, 2020, 2021 | Earth on a wall |
| Earth of the Great Station | 1968, 1969 | Broad ground, marshland |
| Earth in the Sand | 1976, 1977 | Sandy earth |
| Earth on the City Wall | 1998, 1999 | Rampart earth |
In Na Yin readings, Earth on the City Wall meeting Earth by the Roadside or Earth on the Wall is usually interpreted through their similarity in material and stability.
Even so, five-element harmony does not mean two people will certainly get along in marriage or business. Real outcomes also depend on each person’s character, communication and goals.
Is Earth on the City Wall compatible with Metal?
Earth on the City Wall and Metal have a generating relationship in the direction of Earth generating Metal.
In five-element belief, Metal forms and accumulates within the earth. So Earth is seen as nourishing Metal and enabling it to develop.
However, the direction of generation must be understood correctly. When Earth on the City Wall meets Metal, Earth is the outflowing side and Metal is the side being generated.
This differs from Fire generating Earth, where Earth on the City Wall receives support.
In traditional reading, if there is too much outflow, the generating side can be depleted. So Earth generating Metal is usually judged as generating but requiring attention to balance.
One Metal Na Yin mentioned when read with Earth on the City Wall is White Wax Metal, with the image of metal being smelted.
In addition, Gold in the Sea, Gold in the Sand, Gold Leaf Metal and some other Metal Na Yin also fall under Earth generating Metal by the general principle.
Whether a pair of Na Yin is favorable must be judged by a specific method rather than concluded from the element name alone.
Which elements clash with Earth on the City Wall?
Under the five-element controlling rules, Earth on the City Wall has controlling relationships with Wood and Water. However, the direction of control differs in the two relationships.
Wood controls Earth, meaning the Earth element is controlled by Wood. Conversely, Earth controls Water, meaning Earth is the controller of Water.
In feng shui readings, this is the basis for considering clashes between people of different Na Yin.
Earth on the City Wall and Wood
Wood represents trees, growth and development. In the five elements, Wood controls Earth because trees draw nutrients from the soil and their roots can affect its structure.
For the image of Earth on the City Wall, trees growing vigorously on a rampart can damage its structure over time. So the combination of Earth on the City Wall and Wood is usually classed as a controlling relationship.
Wood Na Yin such as Wood of the Great Forest, Pine and Cypress Wood, Willow Wood or Wood of the Plains all have the Wood attribute but each has its own image.
Notably, some Na Yin texts hold that certain kinds of Wood do not harm Earth on the City Wall and may even create a symbolically supportive relationship.
So Wood controlling Earth is a basic principle, not an absolute conclusion for every pair of Na Yin.
Earth on the City Wall and Water
Earth controlling Water is the second controlling relationship to consider.
In natural imagery, earth can form dykes, stop water or limit its flow. For Earth on the City Wall, the rampart is imagined as a structure able to protect and block outside forces.
However, large volumes of water can also cause erosion, affecting the structure of the earth and the ramparts.
This leads to different interpretations for different Water Na Yin. For example, Water in the Ravine represents water in a gully, while Great Sea Water carries the image of a vast ocean. These two Na Yin may be viewed differently when placed beside Earth on the City Wall.
Some texts even read Earth on the City Wall meeting Great Sea Water as favorable in certain cases when the earthly branches of the two ages are also considered. So don’t assert that every Water Na Yin is unfavorable to the same degree.
Which colors suit Earth on the City Wall?
Besides knowing which elements Earth on the City Wall is compatible with, color is also a frequent concern when choosing clothing, vehicles, furniture or decorations.
In the five elements, Earth on the City Wall belongs to Earth, so Fire colors and the native Earth colors are usually recommended.
Fire colors are seen as generating, while Earth colors express harmony.
Table of suitable colors and colors to limit for Earth on the City Wall
| Color group | Colors | Five-element relationship |
| Supporting colors | Red, pink, cam, purple | Fire generates Earth |
| Harmonizing colors | Earthy yellow, earthy brown, beige | Same element Earth |
| Outflowing colors | White, gray, silver | Earth generates Metal |
| Water-element colors | Black, blue | Earth controls Water |
| Controlling colors | Green, leaf green, moss green | Wood controls Earth |
Of these, earthy yellow and brown are usually seen as the choices that most clearly express the stability of Earth on the City Wall.
Red, orange or purple tones can be used as accents, based on the idea of Fire generating Earth.
Conversely, green, which belongs to Wood, is usually advised against if you want to choose colors by traditional five-element rules.
Using colors that suit Earth on the City Wall in daily life
Clothing colors
For everyday clothing, Earth on the City Wall people can consider brown, beige, earthy yellow or terracotta orange.
These are also neutral or warm tones that are easy to combine with many styles.
Red, pink and purple can be used as accents on tops, handbags or accessories.
However, clothing choices should still prioritize suitability for the occasion, personal taste and skin tone.
Car colors
In five-element belief, red, orange, yellow or brown cars are considered suitable for people with the Earth on the City Wall Na Yin.
Of these, yellow and brown represent Earth, while red and orange belong to Fire.
Even so, a car’s color does not determine road safety. Vehicle quality, visibility, regular maintenance and obeying traffic laws matter more.
Interior colors and living spaces
In home design, earth tones are often used to create a warm, stable feeling close to nature.
People interested in Earth on the City Wall feng shui can consider wood brown, cream yellow, beige or terracotta orange for living rooms and shared spaces.
However, there’s no need to use a single color. Harmonious color combinations with good lighting and well-used space can create a more comfortable home.
The personality of Earth on the City Wall people in feng shui belief
The image of a solid rampart means Earth on the City Wall is often associated with qualities such as steadfastness, responsibility and the ability to protect others.
In folk readings, people of this Na Yin are usually described as principled, valuing stability and not easily changing their decisions.
Steadfast and responsible
Ramparts are built to last and protect an area. So Earth on the City Wall is seen as a symbol of endurance, holding one’s ground and a sense of responsibility.
In this interpretation, Earth on the City Wall people are often associated with being trustworthy, keeping their promises and wanting to build a solid foundation in life.
Valuing stability
The Earth element in general is usually associated with stability and the ability to maintain order.
Earth on the City Wall is interpreted as tending to be cautious about major changes, preferring clear plans and wanting to limit uncertainty.
Can be inflexible in some situations
The downside of the rampart image is rigidity.
In traditional reading, steadfastness taken too far can become conservatism, difficulty accepting new ideas or reluctance to adjust plans.
However, these traits are only symbolic descriptions within the Na Yin system. Birth year is not a scientific basis for determining a person’s actual character.
Which ages suit Earth on the City Wall in marriage and business?
When checking compatibility for marriage or business partnerships, the Na Yin element is often one of the factors consulted.
By generating relationships, Earth on the City Wall people may consider ages belonging to Fire, Earth or Metal. However, a traditional compatibility reading also requires checking the heavenly stems, earthly branches and other systems depending on the method.
For example, people born in 1998 (Wu Yin) and 1999 (Ji Mao) are both Earth on the City Wall. The two ages share a Na Yin, but that doesn’t mean every factor in a compatibility reading is the same.
For the Wu Yin age, the branch relationships usually consulted include the Tiger – Horse – Dog Three Harmonies group. The Ji Mao age, meanwhile, belongs to the Pig – Rabbit – Goat Three Harmonies group.
So choosing a spouse or business partner based only on Na Yin does not fully reflect the traditional system of compatibility.
In marriage, shared values, communication and the responsibility of both people have more practical meaning. In business, prioritize professional competence, transparency and a clear partnership agreement.
Which house directions suit Earth on the City Wall?
In five-element feng shui, the Earth element is linked with the center, the Northeast and the Southwest.
So some texts often mention the Northeast and Southwest when exploring directions belonging to Earth.
However, the Earth on the City Wall Na Yin alone cannot be used to determine a suitable house direction for everyone born in 1998 or 1999.
In Eight Mansions feng shui, directions are usually determined from the Gua number of the owner or person concerned, which depends on birth year and gender under the traditional calculation.
The Gua number and the Na Yin element are two different concepts. So two Earth on the City Wall people may still be read as having different house directions.
Besides feng shui, choosing a house direction should also take into account sunlight, wind, ventilation, climate and the practical conditions of the building.
Editorial information
Written byTechnical & Visual Design TeamThe unit that designs visual diagrams and keeps the website secure.
Reviewed byContent Review BoardThe unit that screens material and verifies its accuracy.
Last updated: 21/11/2026
References
- JAHH 2019 PDF
- Aslaksen, The Mathematics of the Chinese Calendar
- Ho Ngoc Duc, Leipzig University
- UNESCO, Twenty-Four Solar Terms
- Truong Anh Thuan, The Hiep Ky calendar under the Nguyen dynasty
- Smith, Chinese Almanacs (book review)
- Smith, Fortune-tellers and Philosophers (book review)
- Ziwei doushu, Wikipedia
- Bruun, An Introduction to Feng Shui
- Feuchtwang, LSE eprints
- Bourassa & Peng 1999
- Bond, Feng Shui and Condominium Prices
Content follows our editorial standards of Treasure Land Feng Shui. Results are for reference, based on traditional beliefs.


